Rail Consultant Defends Report


BY JIM DOOLEY – The state-paid consultant that studied Honolulu’s rail transit project has disputed Mayor Peter Carlisle’s description of its work as shoddy and biased.

Steve Steckler, chairman of Infrastructure Management Group, Inc., said his company’s analysis of the Honolulu project “was intended to be constructive” and was developed independently and without a pre-determined outcome.

“We do not second-guess the City’s decision to develop a rail line, nor do we conclude that it is financially infeasible,” Stckler wrote in an email.

“Rather, we conclude simply that the current financial plan should be improved and that the City will need additional local financial resources to complete and operate the rail system,” Steckler said.

The study, commissioned by outgoing Gov. Linda Lingle at a cost of $350,000, projected that city tax revenues might fall as much as $1.7 billion short of the estimated ultimate price tag of $5.2 billion. IMG also said the City’s ridership estimates might be too high.

Carlisle said Friday that a “prominent member” of the IMG team, Thomas Rubin, is “a nationally-known anti-rail activist.”

“It is no surprise the report is a pre-determined anti-rail rant,” the mayor said.

Steckler said Rubin was hired by IMG as a sub-consultant “to review the rail project’s operating plan and the experience of other rail projects.”

Rubin’s work was not part of IMG’s financial analysis, according to Steckler.

The IMG report’s financial figures “exend” earlier concerns about the Honolulu rail project that were identified in a 2009 consultant report written for the Federal Transit Administration, Steckler said.

IMG was “left alone” by the Lingle administration when it was preparing its report, according to Steckler.

IMG has worked closely with Parsons Brinckerhoff, the prime engineering consultant for the Honolulu rail project, on other studies, said Steckler.

“We regard Parsons Brinckerhoff’s work on the (Honolulu) rail project as nothing less than professional,” Steckler continued.

“ We only wish that we had had unfettered access to them as part of our review,” he added.



Previous articleDjou: Free Trade Deal with South Korea Will Help U.S. and Hawaii
Next articleFinancial Trouble: State of Emergency Declared at Guam Memorial Hospital
Jim Dooley joined the Hawaii Reporter staff as an investigative reporter in October 2010. Before that, he has worked as a print and television reporter in Hawaii since 1973, beginning as a wire service reporter with United Press International. He joined Honolulu Advertiser in 1974, working as general assignment and City Hall reporter until 1978. In 1978, he moved to full-time investigative reporting in for The Advertiser; he joined KITV news in 1996 as investigative reporter. Jim returned to Advertiser 2001, working as investigative reporter and court reporter until 2010. Reach him at Jim@hawaiireporter.com