Former Congressman Ed Case: If Hirono Wins U.S. Senate Democratic Primary, Former GOP Gov. Lingle Will Beat Her

article top
Ed Case on Hawaii Reporter television

BY MALIA ZIMMERMAN – Former Hawaii Congressman Ed Case, (2002-2007), took aim this week at the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee’s endorsement of Congresswoman Mazie Hirono, who he is challenging in the 2012 Senatorial election.

Case, a Blue dog Democrat who served in congress from 2002 to 2007, criticized the group for being “D.C. insiders,” in a statement to The Hill this week.


Both Case and Hirono want to replace the retiring U.S. Sen. Daniel Akaka, D-Hawaii. Whoever wins the primary will take on former Republican Governor Linda Lingle in the general election.

Case’s rocky relationship with the DSCC culminated on Tuesday with Chairwoman Patty Murray, D-Wash., endorsement of Hirono. Murray told reporters: “I’m supporting Mazie, and I believe she is going to win.”

Case told the Washington DC-based media, The Hill, “While Mazie’s been selling her candidacy to the DC insiders, I’ve taken mine straight to Hawaii’s voters, who aren’t too interested in Washington telling them how to fix Washington.”

Hawaii Reporter television with Ed Case

Case, who made an appearance on Hawaii Reporter television this week, is a fiscal moderate who has challenged his Democratic party’s status quo both in Hawaii and Washington DC. He notes Hirono was rated the 6th most liberal member of the U.S. House.

Unlike Hirono, he opposes the Jones Act, the American shipping law that protects American companies from foreign competition and raises the cost of goods in Hawaii by as much as 30 percent.

His top issues are accountability in government, the budget deficit in Washington, boosting the economy and job creation.

Fundraising in this economy has been a focus and a challenge.

While Case said he has “grassroots” support, he suggests Hirono has about 38 percent of her money coming from special interest. Lingle said she will raise $8 million to $10 million for her campaign, and has been traveling throughout the mainland states these last few weeks to continue to reach that goal. “There is not $8 million to $10 million in Hawaii for this race,” Case said.

Case lost his congressional seat after he ran against Akaka in a 2006 primary, a move that infuriated Hawaii’s Senior Senator Daniel Inouye, D-Hawaii.

Inouye has spoken out against Case and campaigned for his Democratic challengers including Colleen Hanabusa in the 2010 Congressional Election and Hirono in this Senatorial race.

Case said while he was disappointed that Inouye is backing Hirono, he does not believe Hawaii’s entire congressional delegation feels the same.

And while Inouye is Hawaii’s most senior senator, and respected among his fellow party members, Case said he is skeptical Democrats will vote for one candidate over the other just because Inouye instructs them to.

Ed Case

In his recent spree of “talk story” sessions across the state, he said he often gets asked what Hirono has accomplished in Congress, because her constituents are not convinced there have been memorable or significant accomplishments.

Case, who calls this U.S. Senate race, Hawaii’s most important election in a generation, maintains if Hirono wins the Democratic primary, former GOP Gov. Linda Lingle will beat Hirono in the November general election.





  1. Ed’s not a good choice for Senate. Mazie’s a horrid choice. Lingle is the best of an undistinguished bunch… I wish she was better, but she’s the only one who could grow into playing a reasonable center-right role for Hawaii in the U.S. Senate.

  2. Case …. maintains if Hirono wins the Democratic primary, former GOP Gov. Linda Lingle will beat Hirono in the November general election.

    Ed Case should be the last expert to make predictions of this nature. He would have been a shoo-in for the Senate seat if he had just waited his turn in line instead of his ill attempt to mug Akaka. Don’t ya think. Heck, Case would have been the mayor if he had ran for the office on the momentum and votes he received in his failed run against Hanabusa for the House seat combined with the partisan votes he would theoretically have received from the Hanabusa camp.

    Although I personally feel that Linge did as good a job as humanly possible as governor, there remains the issue of what entitles her to run for Senate with the House seat up for grabs other than by virtue of her credentials as former Gov, that she is entitled to cherry pick the better position and voters will not see that as overambitious or as if she thinks herself above everybody else, even finicky. Traditionally here people have served in the House than moved up to the more prestigious Senate and nobody to my knowledge had a huge problems with that except Case. That’s how it’s usually done in other states as well. If you note, D’jou isn’t running for the Senate seat. I realize that Lingle may have not wanted to contest fellow republican D’jou for the House seat on the republican ticket, but that’s probably secondary.

  3. The only way Hirono wins is dependent on the mindless voting of the Nisei generation, i.e. “just vote for the person with (D) next to his/her name”. Accomplishments or credentials don’t really matter.

Comments are closed.