• Home
  • News
  • Special Features
    • Environment
    • Guest Commentary
    • Heroes of the Pacific
    • On Target Shooting Sports
  • Business & Tech
    • Consumer Tech
    • Personal Finance
    • ThinkTech
  • Life
    • Arts & Culture
    • Food
    • Health
    • Spiritual Practice
    • Travel
    • Work/Career
  • Entertainment
Sign in
Welcome!Log into your account
Forgot your password?
Password recovery
Recover your password
Search
Monday, June 27, 2022
Sign in
Welcome! Log into your account
Forgot your password? Get help
Password recovery
Recover your password
A password will be e-mailed to you.
Hawaii Reporter
  • Home
  • News
  • Special Features
    • AllEnvironmentGuest CommentaryHeroes of the PacificOn Target Shooting Sports

      Maui No Ka $$

      Prepping healthy food with kitchen appliances for the Covid Era

      A Consumer’s Guide to Navigating the Current Bear Markets — Part…

      Free-fall – Posts offering perspective and commentary on art and global…

  • Business & Tech
    • AllConsumer TechPersonal FinanceThinkTech

      Prepping healthy food with kitchen appliances for the Covid Era

      Blame the feds for inflation, but there ways to minimize the…

      A Consumer’s Guide to Navigating the Current Bear Markets — Part…

      A Consumer’s Guide to Navigating the Current Bear Markets — Part…

  • Life
    • AllArts & CultureFoodHealthSpiritual PracticeTravelWork/Career

      Maui No Ka $$

      Prepping healthy food with kitchen appliances for the Covid Era

      Free-fall – Posts offering perspective and commentary on art and global…

      The Warlord’s Hospital and Other Stories–a memoir from Jim Mielke

  • Entertainment
    • BEYOND MONET: The Immersive Experience Opens June 15 at Hawaii Convention…

      Free-fall – “We Can Fix It “ – A series…

      Sex RE-Education 101 

      Free-fall – A perspective and commentary on art, global and environmental…

      Hawaii International Film Festival offers platform to launch authentic Polynesian films

Home Special Features Guest Commentary The New County TAT Earmarks Aren’t the Real Problem
  • Special Features
  • Guest Commentary
  • Life

The New County TAT Earmarks Aren’t the Real Problem

By
Tom Yamachika
-
December 20, 2021
0
3101

Honolulu, just like most of the other neighbor Island counties, has passed a 3% addition to the Transient Accommodations Tax (TAT).

It had to.

The State was giving it millions of dollars a year in revenue sharing, but in 2020 the Governor shut off the spigot using his emergency powers and in 2021 the legislature made that permanent.  “We’ll keep the money permanently,” they said, “but you counties can enact a TAT of your own.”

Here in Honolulu, enactment of the county TAT was pretty much a foregone conclusion.  But there was lots and lots of debate over earmarking the money.  This much goes to the General Fund.  This much goes to the Transit Fund (i.e., rail).  The final version of the bill also sets up a special account in the general fund, which must be used to “mitigate the impacts of visitors on public facilities and natural resources, including the restoration, operations, and maintenance of beaches and parks,” and to “supplement, and not supplant, any funds regularly appropriated for those purposes.

May I suggest, though, that these debates are meaningless.

Suppose I had three bank accounts, one called “General,” one for “Vacation,” and one for “House Maintenance.”  I dutifully put some money into each account every month, pay my house maintenance expenses out of the House Maintenance account, and pay other expenses out of the General account.

Then tragedy strikes!  My spouse gets sick and has to go to the hospital.  Because I don’t have a diamond-studded platinum health plan, the health insurance only pays a certain percentage of the hospital bill, leaving a good chunk for me to absorb.  My mortgage is due in a few days, and my General account doesn’t have enough to pay it.  Do I preserve the other two accounts, let the mortgage fall into default, and cringe while waiting for the foreclosure notice?  Not a chance.

The Honolulu rail project is hitting some serious bumps in the track. 

The wheels don’t fit the rails (or the rails don’t fit the wheels). 

Someone forgot that there’s electric power needed to get a train moving – a lot of power –every time a train leaves a station, so that other customers on the power grid might be impacted if the trains simply pull power out of the grid without doing anything to protect the other users.

And now, HART needs to start building the rail track in urban Honolulu, which is going to be quite a bit more complicated, and may contain more surprises, than building in the suburbs or in rural areas.

These surprises may require more than the Transit Fund is going to have.  Are we going to preserve the General Fund and the visitor mitigation (or whatever it’s going to be called) fund while letting the City & County of Honolulu go into default, wrecking its bond ratings in the process? 

Although that decision may be made by future City Councils and not this one, we can bet that we won’t be worrying about the integrity of the special funds as much as we would be worrying about how to pay the City’s bills.

Which is why, when we are examining county council actions like this one, we need to pay more attention to the reality of the action (a new tax is being imposed) rather than the “earmarks” on that tax (which may become entirely meaningless once financial reality sets in).  As voters and taxpayers, I suggest we be more watchful of what issues are threatening to give us even more cost overruns, and that we insist that our politicians who are (or want to be) in that office give us some action on those issues now.

Like this:

Like Loading...

Comments

comments

  • TAGS
  • County TAT
  • earmarks
  • general fund
  • HART
  • Hawaii State Legislature
  • Honolulu City Council
  • Rail
  • special account
  • transit fund
Facebook
Twitter
Pinterest
WhatsApp
    Previous articleHawaii International Film Festival offers platform to launch authentic Polynesian films
    Next articleKeeping the lead out of your life with Hygenall and surgical gloves
    Tom Yamachika
    https://www.tfhawaii.org/wordpress/

    RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR

    Guest Commentary

    Maui No Ka $$

    Consumer Tech

    Prepping healthy food with kitchen appliances for the Covid Era

    Business & Tech

    A Consumer’s Guide to Navigating the Current Bear Markets — Part 2

    LEAVE A REPLY Cancel reply

    Log in to leave a comment

    Recent Comments

    • Rob Kinslow on Mission: Joy – Documentary celebrates friendship between Desmond Tutu and the Dalai Lama screened at HIFF
    • NRA Promotes Charles Cotton and Willes Lee, Two Execs Who Spread Bonkers Conspiracies - Lord Web on Interview with Willes Lee, first local candidate for NRA Board Member
    • NRA Promotes Charles Cotton and Willes Lee, Two Execs Who Unfold Bonkers Conspiracies - 𝟙𝟙𝕥𝕙 ℍ𝕠𝕦𝕣 ℕ𝕖𝕨𝕤 on Interview with Willes Lee, first local candidate for NRA Board Member
    • The NRA Promotes Charles Cotton And Wells Lee, Two Execs Who Spread Bonkers Conspiracies. - GreeleyTribune.Net on Interview with Willes Lee, first local candidate for NRA Board Member
    • High-Risk Vaccine Hesitancy – Disability Visibility Project on Living with Cerebral Spinal Fluid Leaks

    Looking for something?

    Get Hawaii Reporter Email Updates

    Enter your email address to subscribe and receive notifications of new posts by email.

    EDITOR PICKS

    Maui No Ka $$

    Prepping healthy food with kitchen appliances for the Covid Era

    Blame the feds for inflation, but there ways to minimize the...

    POPULAR POSTS

    Heads Up! The Way You Are Sleeping May Be Killing...

    It pays not to work: Hawaii residents receive highest welfare benefits...

    “Accurizing” the Glock G40 MOS

    POPULAR CATEGORY

    • News8811
    • Guest Commentary5477
    • Business & Tech1768
    • Today in Hawaii1365
    • Archive653
    • Special Features637
    • Hawaii Politics601
    • Education460
    • Life450
    ABOUT US
    Hawaii Reporter. News. Opinion. Entertainment. The UN-MEDIA.
    • Archives
    • Terms of Use
    • Privacy Policy
    • About us
    © Copyright 2017 - Hawaii Reporter
    %d bloggers like this: